The 2026 philosophy teaching methods study by Friso Timmenga and Indira van der Zande finds that university philosophy teachers aim for argumentation, critical engagement and intellectual growth. They often judge whether those aims are met through intuition rather than fixed measures. The paper, “Evaluating and diversifying philosophy education,” appeared in Learning and Instruction as article 102369 in volume 104. It draws on semi-structured interviews with 18 instructors at universities in seven countries, twelve of them in the Netherlands.
The sharpest disagreement concerns transformation, meaning teaching that explicitly seeks to change a student’s self or world. When asked whether philosophy education should be transformative, 10 of the 18 participants answered yes, 6 held mixed views, and 2 rejected the aim. Teachers who embraced it found transformation hard to assess, so they relied on noticing student development and sensing the atmosphere in the room. They also warned that encounters with philosophical and cultural difference can unsettle students, which calls for careful facilitation. If you are weighing a course resource, check its stated aims first. A syllabus that promises transformation needs some way to show it.
18
University philosophy teachers interviewed across seven countries
10 of 18
Teachers who said philosophy education should be transformative
2 of 18
Teachers who rejected transformation as an aim
7
Countries where the interviewed teachers’ universities are located
Quick Facts
- Study citation: Timmenga and van der Zande’s 2026 paper, “Evaluating and diversifying philosophy education,” appeared in Learning and Instruction as article 102369 in volume 104.
- Sample size and spread: The study interviewed 18 university philosophy teachers at universities in seven countries, and 12 of the 18 worked in the Netherlands.
- Views on transformation: When asked whether philosophy education should be transformative, 10 of 18 teachers answered yes, 6 held mixed views, and 2 rejected the aim.
- Interview saturation: The researchers reported reaching saturation after the 15th interview, the point at which later conversations stopped adding substantially new themes.
- Interview languages: Interviews were conducted in English (9), Dutch (6), French (2) and German (1).
Key Takeaways
- University philosophy teachers in the 2026 Timmenga and van der Zande study aim for argumentation, critical engagement and intellectual growth, and often judge whether those aims are met through intuition rather than fixed measures.
- Transformation, meaning teaching that explicitly seeks to change a student’s self or world, divided the 18 interviewed teachers, with 10 saying philosophy education should be transformative, 6 holding mixed views, and 2 rejecting the aim.
- If you are weighing a course resource, check its stated aims first, because a syllabus that promises transformation needs some way to show that change actually happened.
- Encounters with philosophical and cultural difference can unsettle students in a philosophy course, so you should plan careful facilitation before adding unfamiliar perspectives.
What the 2026 Study Found About Philosophy Teaching Aims
The study used semi-structured interviews and thematic analysis. The researchers asked each teacher open questions about what they were trying to achieve and how they knew it had happened, then grouped the answers into shared themes. Interviews were conducted in English (9), Dutch (6), French (2) and German (1). The researchers reported reaching saturation after the 15th interview, the point at which later conversations stopped adding substantially new themes.
Transformation drew more questions from participants than any other topic. When they asked what the term meant, the researchers offered a working definition: an approach that explicitly seeks to bring about a transformation in a student’s self and/or world. The definition contains two choices that matter. The first is the word “explicitly,” which separates a course that happens to change its students from one that sets out to change them on purpose. The second is the “and/or,” which allows for change in how a student sees themselves, change in how they see and act in the world, or both.
Those two choices help explain why the teachers disagreed. A teacher focused on a student’s growing confidence in their own reasoning and a teacher focused on how students engage with social questions could both describe their work as transformative, yet they would be pointing at different outcomes. The disagreement was therefore not only about whether transformation is good, but about what the word should cover in the first place.
The question of whether transformation should be stated as an aim was equally divided. Teachers who supported it were willing to write it into their goals. Those who hesitated worried that announcing personal change as a purpose could sit uneasily with the open-ended inquiry that argumentation is meant to protect. For a teacher, this is a practical tension. A stated goal gives direction, but it also raises the question of how success will be recognised, and the interviews suggest that many instructors had no settled method for answering it.
Keep the sample in view, too. Twelve of the eighteen teachers worked in the Netherlands, so the findings are best read as an exploratory picture of how one group thinks about its aims, not a map of philosophy teaching across all universities. Even so, the disagreements the interviews surfaced are likely to be familiar to instructors in many settings. They also offer a useful checklist for reading any course description that uses words like “transformation,” “growth” or “critical engagement.”
How Was the Study Designed and Who Took Part?

The study is a qualitative project. It relies on semi-structured interviews with 18 university philosophy teachers, and the transcripts were analysed through thematic analysis, a method that groups answers into shared themes. Each teacher was asked open questions about what they were trying to achieve and how they knew it had happened. The interviews are the core of the evidence, so the design shapes what the findings can tell you.
The teachers came from universities in seven countries, and the sample was not spread evenly across them. The table below shows how many participants each country contributed.
Sample of 18 teachers by country of affiliation
| Country | Teachers interviewed |
|---|---|
| Netherlands | 12 |
| Switzerland | 1 |
| Japan | 1 |
| Colombia | 1 |
| South Africa | 1 |
| France | 1 |
| Tunisia | 1 |
| Total | 18 |
Interviews were not all held in one language. Nine took place in English, six in Dutch, two in French and one in German. This is a practical point to keep in mind when you compare phrases such as “transformation” or “critical engagement” across sources.
The researchers reported reaching saturation after the 15th interview, meaning later conversations no longer produced substantially new themes. The study nonetheless went on to 18 interviews.
The authors also set out limits of their own. The 18-person sample was disproportionately affiliated with Dutch universities, and the authors state that the exploratory findings cannot support broad generalisations. A single country’s teachers may share institutional expectations, language and assessment habits that a wider group would not, so the results are best treated as a detailed picture of one set of perspectives.
What Is a Teaching Philosophy Statement?
A teaching philosophy statement is a short written account of what you aim for in your teaching and why. It names the outcomes you hope students reach and gives the reasons behind the way you structure your sessions, readings and assessments. Its purpose is to make your intentions explicit, so you and your readers can see what you are trying to do.
A statement is different from a general educational philosophy. A general theory of education is a broad position on what schooling is for, such as whether it should prepare citizens, train workers, or cultivate thinking for its own sake. A personal statement is narrower. It describes one teacher, in one subject, working with particular students. A statement may draw on a general theory, but it is not one. It records how you apply your views to a specific course.
Two terms help make this concrete. Pedagogy is the practice and study of teaching, covering the choices about how material is presented, how discussion is run, how students are guided and how their work is judged. Pedagogical Content Knowledge is a term from education research for the knowledge a teacher needs to teach one particular subject well, as opposed to general teaching skill. It includes knowing which examples, analogies or representations make a difficult idea clear to learners. A 2026 peer-reviewed study of an experienced philosophy lecturer in Argentina describes that teacher using metaphors, analogies, embodiment and sensory engagement to teach abstract concepts. It is a concrete example of this kind of knowledge at work.
The study’s categories of aims map naturally onto what a statement might say. A statement that names argumentation might explain that students are expected to build, test and defend arguments, and to notice weak points in their own reasoning. A statement that names critical engagement might describe how students evaluate texts and positions, including positions they end up rejecting. A statement that names intellectual growth might describe the habits of thought you hope students develop over a whole term or programme.
Transformation needs more care. If you write it into a statement, say whether you mean change in a student’s sense of self, in how they see and act in the world, or both. You should also say what evidence would show that change has happened. The interviews suggest that many teachers have no settled answer to that last question, so a statement that promises transformation without naming its signs leaves readers with a promise they cannot check.
Much of the advice available online treats the teaching philosophy statement mainly as a job document, a piece of application material written to persuade a hiring panel. This article takes a different view. It treats the statement as a record of pedagogical aims, something you can return to and compare with what actually happens in class. That approach keeps the statement useful after the application is over.
Once an aim is written down, it raises a practical question about assessment. In 2026, the American Philosophical Association and American Association of Philosophy Teachers invited discussion of approaches including authentic projects, co-created assignments, ungrading, specifications grading, standards-based grading, contract grading and labor-based grading. A statement that names an aim should also indicate which of these methods, or which combination, is meant to show that the aim is being met.
How Do Educational Philosophies Compare in Practice?

Educational philosophies differ mainly in what they treat as the purpose of learning and where they locate its source: in the learner’s activity, in a fixed body of knowledge, in observable behaviour, or in the student’s own cultural background. Each one points a philosophy class toward different activities and different ways of judging work.
Constructivism holds that learners build understanding actively, by testing ideas against their own experience. Social constructivism adds that much of this building happens through dialogue, so meaning is worked out in shared conversation. In a philosophy seminar, that means students test a thought experiment against their own intuitions and against their classmates’ objections.
Progressivism starts from student experience and inquiry, so the questions students bring can shape the course. Essentialism holds that a core body of knowledge and disciplined study should come first, because open inquiry works best on stable foundations. A progressive philosophy course might be organised around a question the class chooses, while an essentialist one might move through canonical texts such as Plato, Aristotle and Descartes in a fixed order, read closely.
Behaviorism concentrates on observable outcomes and the reinforcement of specified behaviours. In philosophy, this could look like repeated practice in identifying premises and conclusions, with immediate feedback on each attempt. Culturally responsive teaching connects content to students’ backgrounds and perspectives, so the examples and debates in a course draw on the communities students come from.
| Approach | Core emphasis | Typical philosophy-class activity | Likely assessment focus |
|---|---|---|---|
| Constructivism | Understanding built through activity | Working through thought experiments and rebuilding arguments in small groups | Written explanations of reasoning and revised drafts |
| Social constructivism | Understanding built through dialogue | Structured seminars, peer objections and shared argument maps | Quality of contributions to discussion and responses to peers |
| Progressivism | Learning grows from experience and inquiry | Student-chosen questions and research projects | Process portfolios and inquiry reports |
| Essentialism | Core knowledge and disciplined study | Close reading of canonical texts and structured exposition | Examinations on core texts and essays against a fixed standard |
| Behaviorism | Observable outcomes and reinforcement | Drills in identifying premises and conclusions with immediate feedback | Rubric-scored tasks and checklists of named skills |
| Culturally responsive teaching | Connecting content to students’ backgrounds | Comparing ethical cases drawn from students’ own communities | Reasoning that draws on varied perspectives, judged against criteria stated in advance |
The families overlap more than their labels suggest. Constructivism and progressivism both treat activity as central to learning, and progressivism and culturally responsive teaching both begin with what students already bring. Essentialism and behaviorism both care about clear standards, although they differ on whether those standards should be knowledge-based or skill-based.
The 2026 study’s interviews show instructors combining several aims, such as argumentation, critical engagement and intellectual growth. Six of the eighteen participants held mixed views on whether transformation should be an aim at all. Blending aims is therefore not a compromise that weakens a course; it is a pattern that appears in these interviews.
If you are comparing course resources, look for the mix rather than the label. A syllabus might use essentialist core texts, social constructivist seminars and rubric-based checks on argument skills, and each choice should be visible in the readings, the tasks and the grading criteria. A resource that names one philosophy but assesses in a different way deserves a closer look.
How Do Teachers Judge Whether Teaching Works?
Teachers judge whether their teaching works by comparing what they hoped students would achieve with the evidence they can gather. For hard-to-measure aims such as transformation, that evidence is often informal. The 2026 study found that teachers who embraced transformation often found it difficult to evaluate, so they relied on intuitive judgments, such as watching how a student’s thinking developed or sensing the atmosphere in the room. Intuition can point a teacher toward something important, but it is hard to check and hard to explain to a colleague or a student.
Assessment practice offers several alternatives for making judgments more explicit. The 2026 Teaching Hub session on assessment invited discussion of ungrading, which withholds letter grades in favour of detailed feedback and revision. Specifications grading sets out a list of named tasks, and a student who completes a given set reaches a given grade. Standards-based grading reports performance against stated standards, such as constructing a valid argument or identifying a hidden premise, rather than against an overall average. Contract grading fixes the grade in advance according to an agreement about the amount and quality of work a student will produce. Labor-based grading rewards the time and effort students put into the course, not only the quality of the final product.
Two other forms of assessment sit alongside these. Authentic projects ask students to produce work that resembles real philosophical activity, such as a short public essay, a brief for a class debate or a considered reply to a published argument. Co-created assignments invite students to help shape the task or its criteria, which can make the standards clearer to the people being judged against them. Both forms give the teacher something concrete to examine, which is useful when the aim itself is hard to see directly.
A June 2026 peer-reviewed study of an experienced philosophy lecturer in Argentina shows how teaching and assessment can connect for abstract material. The lecturer used metaphors, analogies, embodiment and sensory engagement to teach abstract concepts, and the study frames this within Pedagogical Content Knowledge. For an assessor, this suggests a practical check. Ask students to restate an abstract idea in their own analogy or image, then see whether the restatement keeps the original distinction intact. That gives you a concrete artefact to judge, rather than a general impression of understanding.
Intuition and explicit criteria do not have to be rivals. You can write criteria for the parts of a course that show up in student work, such as how accurately a student reconstructs an argument or how fairly they answer an objection. Alongside those criteria, keep a short teaching journal that records impressions of the class, marked clearly as impressions. Over a term, the two records can be compared, and any gap between them becomes a question worth investigating rather than a source of confusion.
No single method is presented here as the best. Each option makes different things visible, and each carries costs in workload, fairness and clarity for students. Which method suits a course depends on its aims, its class size and the institution’s expectations, so the choice remains a matter of informed judgment for each teacher.
How Do You Write and Use a Statement in Jobs, Interviews and Portfolios?

A teaching statement for a job application, interview or portfolio is a short written account of four things: the aims you set for your teaching, the methods you use to pursue them, the evidence you collect about student learning, and your reflection on how well your practice is working. Treating these as separate components keeps the statement from becoming a paragraph of general enthusiasm.
Start with aims, and state them in terms a reader can picture. Instead of saying you want students to become critical thinkers, write what they should be able to do by the end of a term, such as rebuild an opposing argument in its strongest form and identify the premise a conclusion depends on. If you name transformation as an aim, say whether you mean change in a student’s sense of self, in how they act in the world, or both.
Methods describe what happens in the room and on the page. Name the activities, such as a seminar in which students test a thought experiment against their own intuitions, or a reading sequence that moves from Plato to Descartes. For each method, state what it is meant to produce, because a method without a stated purpose is hard for a reader to evaluate.
Evidence of learning answers the question of how you know. Point to the assessments that show progress, such as rubric-scored arguments, drafts with revision notes or a final project, and name the criteria you use. Where an aim is hard to measure, say so, and explain how you record informal observations, perhaps in a teaching journal kept apart from grades. Admitting that limit is more credible than implying a precision you do not have.
Reflection is the part most often left out. Answer three prompts in your own words: What do you want students to be able to do? How do you know whether they can? What would you change if the evidence showed they could not? The first keeps the aim concrete, the second connects it to assessment, and the third turns the statement into a working document rather than a finished claim.
Use plain language, and define any technical term the first time it appears, such as Pedagogical Content Knowledge or standards-based grading. Avoid slogans like “learning is a journey,” because they give a reader nothing to check. A specific question you asked a first-year group does more work than any adjective.
Compare two versions. A full-length statement for an argumentation-focused seminar might open with a classroom scene, set out the aims in order, describe the readings and two assessments, and end with a change you made after a course went differently than planned. A short version, which a panel may request at the start of an application, keeps the same logic in a few sentences: one aim, one method, one piece of evidence and one change. The short version should not drop the evidence sentence, since without it the aim reads as a wish.
Teaching statements are commonly requested for faculty posts, teaching-focused positions and some fellowships, often alongside a CV and sample teaching materials. Read each call closely, because some ask for a brief statement and others ask you to address a particular institution’s teaching mission. Adjust the emphasis, but keep your aims consistent with what you actually do.
In an interview, the statement becomes a reference point. Panel members may ask how you would know that a seminar had worked, or how you would handle a discussion of cultural difference that became uncomfortable. Answers that return to the evidence you named sound more grounded than answers reconstructed from memory. Be ready to explain any gap between an aim and its assessment, since the study’s teachers themselves described that gap as a practical difficulty.
In a portfolio, the statement comes first and the materials follow. Attach a real assignment with its criteria, a few anonymised examples of student work with your comments, and extracts from your teaching journal, marked clearly as impressions. A reader can then check each claim against an artefact. Choose documents that illustrate the aims you named rather than everything you have produced.
Revise the statement as your aims change. Six of the eighteen teachers in the 2026 study held mixed views on whether transformation should be an aim at all, so a question that is still open for you is a good reason to revisit the wording. Date each version, review it after every course or whenever your assessment method changes, and keep earlier drafts so you can see how your thinking moved.
Where Diversity and Difference Meet Classroom Limits
Diversifying philosophy teaching means bringing in voices, traditions and cases that a course might otherwise leave out. The teachers in the study valued this kind of exposure. They saw that students gain from meeting perspectives unlike their own, whether those come from another philosophical tradition, another culture, or a debate that has mostly been carried on outside the familiar canon.
The same teachers warned that such encounters can unsettle students. A text that challenges a familiar assumption, or a case drawn from a community the student does not know, can produce discomfort that is useful for thinking but uneven in its effects. Teachers therefore described a balance to be struck between challenge and classroom safety. Too little challenge leaves a course comfortable and narrow. Too much, handled carelessly, can leave some students feeling exposed.
Practical obstacles make that balance harder to reach. Participants identified limited class time, which leaves little room for additional readings or for long discussion of unfamiliar material. They also named limited resources and the limited knowledge of relevant languages among teachers. A course that wants to include a text in Japanese or French can find that the one person who could guide students through it is not in the room. The same gap can appear with any source whose language the teacher does not read.
Careful facilitation is the study’s response to this tension, but the interviews do not reduce it to a formula. What counts as careful depends on the group, the subject and the difference at stake. A teacher might prepare students before a difficult encounter, keep the discussion centred on the argument rather than on the person who made it, or leave time afterwards for students to say what unsettled them. The study points to the need for this kind of care without prescribing one method, so the choice remains one for each teacher to make with their own class in mind.
For a teacher, the useful question is rarely whether to diversify, but how much, and how quickly, a particular group can absorb. A course might add one unfamiliar perspective to each unit, pair it with a text students already know, and review how they responded before adding more. That kind of judgment connects back to the aims you have stated, because a course that promises critical engagement with other views also needs a plan for the discomfort that engagement can bring.
Using These Findings to Evaluate Your Own Course Resources
Start with one resource you already use or are considering, such as a syllabus, a course description or a reading list. Copy its stated aims onto a single page and mark which of the study’s categories each one matches: argumentation, critical engagement, intellectual growth or transformation. Note separately any aim the resource implies but never states.
If transformation appears, check whether the resource says whether it means change in a student’s sense of self, in how they see the world, or both. Then look for the sign that would show the change had happened. If the resource cannot name one, you have found the same gap the study’s teachers described, and you can ask its authors what evidence they would accept.
Next, match each aim to an assessment. An argumentation aim might be checked with a rubric that scores how accurately a student reconstructs an objection. A transformation aim may need a teaching journal kept apart from grades, with entries marked clearly as impressions.
Finally, look at the readings. If a course depends on a text in a language that neither you nor a colleague reads, plan for that gap before term begins, because limited class time leaves little room to improvise. If your review turns up a question the site has not yet covered, you can send it through the site’s contact form.
Frequently Asked Questions
1. Do I need a teaching philosophy statement if I am not applying for faculty jobs?
You do not need a teaching philosophy statement for every purpose, but it is useful for anyone who teaches, tutors or runs seminars. Its main value is as a record of your aims that you can compare with what actually happens in class. Writing one, even for private use, forces you to name the outcomes you want and the evidence you would accept.
2. How can a graduate student with no teaching experience write a statement?
A graduate student with no classroom experience can still write a statement by describing the aims they would bring to a course and the methods they would use to pursue them. Draw on teaching of any kind, such as tutoring, leading a reading group or running a discussion at a conference, and be clear that the statement describes a plan rather than a track record. Naming one assessment you would use to check whether students reach your aims makes the plan concrete for a reader.
3. Which grading approach suits a logic or ethics course with large enrollments?
Standards-based grading and specifications grading are often easiest to run consistently in a large logic or ethics course, because each task can be checked against a named standard, such as identifying a hidden premise, or against a fixed list of tasks. Rubric-scored tasks with clear criteria also help several markers agree on grades. Authentic projects and co-created assignments usually take more time to read and discuss, so they tend to suit smaller seminars better. The right choice ultimately depends on your class size and your institution’s expectations.



