Youth Moral Disagreement Survey: How Teens and Young Adults Respond to Opponents

youth moral disagreement survey how teens and youn 1794838872728

The 2026 youth moral disagreement survey, published in Social Development on July 6, 2026, found that adolescents and emerging adults were more likely to see opponents as reasonable when the underlying moral or political question was difficult.

The study, by Arvid Samuelson, Aarushi Gupta, and Audun Dahl, drew on a modest sample of 196 participants: 131 adolescents and 65 emerging adults. Those who judged opponents reasonable also reported greater willingness to talk with, or befriend, people who disagreed with them.

196

Young people in the 2026 survey, including 131 adolescents and 65 emerging adults.

p < .001

Strongest reported link: harder moral questions were associated with seeing opponents as more reasonable, in both age groups.

5

Factors linked to seeing opponents as reasonable. These are associations, not proven causes.

3

Reported links to reasonableness. Knowing someone who disagrees, lower political extremity, and recognizing good people can disagree.

Quick Facts

  • Study sample size: The survey included 196 young people: 131 adolescents and 65 emerging adults.
  • Publication details: The study was published July 6, 2026, in Social Development by Arvid Samuelson, Aarushi Gupta, and Audun Dahl.
  • Strongest reported link: Harder moral or political questions were associated with seeing opponents as more reasonable, with significance reported at p < .001 in both age groups.
  • Factors linked to reasonableness: Five factors were linked to seeing opponents as reasonable: issue difficulty, knowing someone who disagrees (p = .001), lower political extremity (p < .001), recognizing that good people can disagree (p = .035), and identifying as male (p = .008).
  • Sample age and caution: Adolescents averaged 15.88 years old and emerging adults averaged 19.83 years old. The sample is modest, and the groups differ in age, sex, and race, so the percentages should not be treated as estimates for all teens and young adults.

Key Takeaways

  • The 2026 youth moral disagreement survey, published in Social Development on July 6, 2026, found that adolescents and emerging adults were more likely to see opponents as reasonable when the underlying moral or political question felt difficult.
  • Association noted: Young people in the survey who judged opponents reasonable also reported greater willingness to talk with or befriend people who disagreed with them, and the two tended to appear together in the data.
  • Knowing someone who holds an opposing view, having less extreme political views, and recognizing that good people can disagree were all linked to seeing opponents as reasonable, so you can use these patterns as ideas to test in your own classroom or family.
  • The survey’s sample of 131 adolescents and 65 emerging adults is modest, and because the two groups also differ in average age, sex, and race, you should not treat the age comparison or its percentages as estimates for all teens and young adults.

What Did the 2026 Youth Moral Disagreement Survey Find?

The study found that adolescents and emerging adults were more likely to call an opponent’s view reasonable when the question felt difficult, and those who did were more willing to talk with or befriend the people who held it. In everyday terms, moral reasonableness means whether you see an opponent’s position as a sensible one that a thoughtful person could hold, rather than as a mistake or a sign of bad faith. The authors, Arvid Samuelson, Aarushi Gupta, and Audun Dahl, published the work on July 6, 2026, in Social Development.

The difficulty pattern appeared in both age groups, with significance reported at p < .001 for adolescents and emerging adults alike. The 2026 Cognitive Development Society abstract book adds that the link held even when participants said an issue had only one right answer. This suggests that a question can feel hard enough to make disagreement seem understandable.

The total sample was 196 people: 131 adolescents and 65 emerging adults. That is enough to reveal patterns within this group, but it is not large enough to treat the percentages as estimates for all young people.

How Was the Survey Designed?

How Was the Survey Designed?

Adolescents and emerging adults were recruited as two separate groups. Each group reacted to moral questions while the researchers recorded how they judged people who disagreed. The adolescent group averaged 15.88 years old and was 54% female and 41% White. The emerging adult group averaged 19.83 years old, was 74% female, and was 45% White, so the groups differ in age and demographic makeup.

Participants responded to two kinds of material. The first was manipulated moral dilemmas, invented scenarios built to isolate a particular moral tension. The second was contemporary politico-moral issues drawn from current public debate. For each item, participants rated how difficult the issue was, how reasonable the opposing stance seemed, and how likely they were to talk with or befriend someone who disagreed with them.

The survey also asked two open-ended questions, one about where people learn about current political issues and one about why people disagree. It recorded social-media use, political discussion, and information seeking as well.

The published abstract is the main summary of the study. The 2026 conference abstract adds detail on the measures and statistical tests. If you want to know exactly how a rating was scored, or which test produced a given p value, consult that document.

Which Factors Were Linked to Seeing Opponents as Reasonable?

Five factors were reported as linked to seeing an opponent’s view as reasonable: how difficult the issue felt, knowing someone who disagrees, lower political extremity, recognizing that good people can disagree, and identifying as male. The table lists each one.

Factor What was reported Significance level
Issue difficulty Adolescents and emerging adults rated disagreement as more reasonable on harder issues, including issues participants said had only one right answer p < .001
Personal knowledge of a disagreeing person Participants were more likely to see opposing views as reasonable when they personally knew someone who held them p = .001
Lower political extremity Less extreme political views were associated with seeing disagreement as reasonable p < .001
Recognizing that good people can disagree Participants who spontaneously explained that people can disagree despite good intentions or reasoning gave higher reasonableness ratings p = .035
Identifying as male An association with identifying as male was also reported p = .008

Every entry in the table is an association, meaning the factor and the reasonableness rating tended to appear together in the data. Knowing a disagreeing friend is linked to seeing opponents as reasonable, which could mean the friendship shapes that view, or that people who already see opponents as reasonable are more likely to make such friends.

A p-value is a way of asking how surprising a result would be if no real connection existed. A value below .001 means a pattern this strong would be very unlikely to appear by chance alone, while .035 is a weaker signal that still falls under the conventional .05 cutoff. A small p-value does not measure how large an effect is, so it should not be read as a sign that one factor matters more in everyday life than another.

Does Age Change How Young People Engage With Opponents?

Does Age Change How Young People Engage With Opponents?

Adolescents averaged 15.88 years old and were 54% female and 41% White, while emerging adults averaged 19.83 years old and were 74% female and 45% White. Because the two groups also differ in sex and race, age is mixed with those other differences in this sample. The published abstract presents its main findings for participants overall.

Broader ideas about moral development offer hypotheses worth testing, not findings. One common hypothesis holds that abstract reasoning keeps maturing through the late teens, so older participants might be better at understanding why thoughtful people reach different conclusions. Another holds that greater independence and wider social exposure in early adulthood could make disagreement feel more ordinary.

Age can also shape disagreement through authority. A teenager who argues with a parent or teacher may experience the disagreement as a power struggle. A generation gap over politics can turn a question about reasonableness into a question about who is in charge.

What Can the Survey Not Show?

The survey describes patterns of association among 196 young people, not causes, population-wide rates, or how these attitudes play out in heated conversations. The sample is modest, with 131 adolescents and 65 emerging adults, so its figures describe this group and should not be read as estimates for all teens and young adults.

When personal experience of disagreement is linked to higher reasonableness ratings, two explanations fit: that experience makes people more open, or that already open people seek out disagreement in the first place.

Ratings of invented dilemmas and survey items are not the same as a tense argument at the dinner table or a debate in a classroom, where friendships, embarrassment, and status shape what people say. The study also did not directly measure school moral education, teacher practice, or arguments between parents and teenagers, so which classroom methods help, and how a family clash over a political issue unfolds, remain open questions.

Keep this study separate from moral relativism, the view that moral truths vary by person or culture. The survey asked whether people judged an opposing stance to be reasonable, which is a question about how people evaluate others’ views. You can find an opponent reasonable while still believing that one answer is correct. The survey measured ratings of opposing stances, not beliefs about moral truth itself.

How Can Parents and Teachers Use These Findings?

How Can Parents and Teachers Use These Findings?

Parents and teachers can use these results as ideas to test, not as recommendations from the study’s authors. The findings link harder questions and personal contact with disagreement to seeing opponents as reasonable. One possibility is structured conversations with people who hold different views, such as a guest panel in a civics class or a monthly family talk with a relative who votes differently.

In classrooms, students often come from families with different values. Asking why reasonable people disagree, not only which answer is correct, may help students see that disagreement can start from different assumptions. A teacher might pose a hard case and ask each student to state the strongest version of a view they reject.

At home, parents can model reasoning out loud, explaining how they weighed the evidence rather than simply announcing a verdict. Disagreement can feel threatening, so it may help to name the emotion, listen until the other person has finished, and look for partial compromise. Handled this way, an argument may leave a teenager more willing to keep talking. That remains a hypothesis to watch for, not a guaranteed outcome.

Where to Start If You Want to Read the Full Study

If you want to read the full study, start with the published abstract in Social Development, which reports the main findings for all 196 participants. Then open the conference abstract to see how each rating was measured and which statistical test produced each p value.

Before you rely on any result, check the sample description. The adolescent and emerging adult groups differ in average age, sex, and race, so the age comparison cannot be separated from those other differences.

If you are a teacher or parent, try a small test yourself. Pick a question your students or children already disagree about, ask each person to state the strongest version of the opposing view, and notice whether the disagreement starts to seem more reasonable.

Frequently Asked Questions

1. Why did the researchers use manipulated moral dilemmas instead of real arguments from young people’s lives?

Invented dilemmas let researchers build a scenario around one specific moral tension, so every participant responds to the same question. Real arguments from young people’s lives are more authentic, but they vary widely in topic, stakes, and the people involved, which makes them hard to compare across 196 participants. The study therefore paired invented dilemmas with contemporary politico-moral issues drawn from current public debate.

2. Do the findings apply to children under fifteen or adults over twenty?

No. The findings describe only the groups the study sampled. Adolescents in the study averaged 15.88 years old and emerging adults averaged 19.83, so the sample says little about younger children or people in their twenties and beyond. Because the two groups also differ in sex and racial makeup, the results should be read as a picture of these particular participants rather than of a general age range.

3. What do the open-ended answers about where people learn political news add to the results?

They add context about where participants’ views come from, which matters for reading the ratings. Someone whose political news comes mostly from sources that share their views may encounter fewer opponents who seem reasonable than someone who follows a mix of sources. The survey also recorded social-media use and information seeking, so these open-ended answers can be read alongside those measures.

4. Can one modest study change how schools teach moral reasoning, and what would stronger evidence look like?

Not on its own. A study of 196 young people can suggest ideas for teachers to test, but it cannot show which classroom methods work, since it did not measure school moral education directly. Stronger evidence would come from larger and more varied samples, studies that follow the same young people over time, and experiments that compare a specific classroom practice against a comparison group.

Scroll to Top