College moral reasoning data from an October 3, 2026 study shows that consequences are the consideration U.S. undergraduates cite most often when they explain everyday ethical choices. In the DePauw University study, 136 students explained their decisions in ten everyday dilemmas, and their written answers were coded across six moral dimensions. Intentions and motivations came second. The published abstract gives no percentages, so the ranking is clear, but the exact shares are not.
136
U.S. undergraduates explained their everyday ethical choices in the DePauw University study
10
Everyday moral dilemmas, covering friendships, coursework, employment, and social life
6
Moral dimensions used to code students’ written explanations
1st
Consequences ranked as the most-cited consideration, ahead of intentions and motivations
Quick Facts
- Sample size and design: The DePauw University study presented 136 U.S. undergraduates with ten everyday dilemmas and coded their written explanations against six moral dimensions.
- Top-ranked consideration: Consequences were the moral consideration students cited most often, ahead of intentions and motivations, which ranked second. The published abstract reports no percentages.
- Study date and source: The study was published October 3, 2026, in Precollege Philosophy and Public Practice as “Morality and Me: An Investigation of a Moral Framework for College Students” by Jillian Lee Meyer and Ted Bitner (DOI 10.5840/p4202693032).
- Dilemma context shifts emphasis: Legal questions drew more attention to principles and rights, while dilemmas involving friends prompted more concern for care and relationships. The study reports these patterns qualitatively, not as percentages.
- Earlier questionnaire record: The Moral Dilemmas Questionnaire surveyed U.S. college students in February 2023 using ten college-relevant dilemmas.
Key Takeaways
- In the DePauw University study of 136 U.S. undergraduates, consequences were the moral consideration students cited most often when explaining everyday ethical choices, followed by intentions and motivations.
- Because the published abstract reports no percentages, you should read the full article by Jillian Lee Meyer and Ted Bitner before quoting any exact share of student explanations from the October 3, 2026 DePauw study.
- The type of dilemma shifted emphasis in the DePauw study, with legal questions drawing more attention to principles and rights and dilemmas involving friends prompting more concern for care and relationships.
- The DePauw study’s coded data captures the reasons students stated in writing, so its mention counts are best read as tendencies rather than a complete account of what shaped each choice.
- The DePauw study rests on one U.S. sample of 136 undergraduates, so its six-dimension counts are a starting point for understanding this group and these ten scenarios, not a universal profile of college students or a stage score comparable to Kohlberg or Defining Issues Test results.
How Was the October 2026 Study Designed?
The study presented 136 U.S. undergraduates with ten everyday dilemmas, asked them to choose a course of action, and had them briefly explain why. Researchers then coded those written explanations against six moral dimensions. The dilemmas covered friendships, coursework, employment, and social life. Because students wrote down the reasons they chose to articulate, the coded data captures stated justifications rather than a full record of what shaped each choice.
The article by Jillian Lee Meyer and Ted Bitner, “Morality and Me: An Investigation of a Moral Framework for College Students,” appears in Precollege Philosophy and Public Practice and is listed under DOI 10.5840/p4202693032. Coders sorted each explanation into consequences, intentions and motivations, principles and rights, care and relationships, virtues, or fairness. The questionnaire has an earlier record, too. A DePauw Spring 2023 Senior Research Symposium description says the Moral Dilemmas Questionnaire surveyed U.S. college students in February 2023, using ten college-relevant dilemmas and asking what they would do and why.
Consequences Lead, but the Gap Is Unmeasured

Consequentialist reasoning judges an action by its outcomes: a choice is right to the extent that it produces good results, such as less harm or more well-being for the people involved. When you explain a decision by pointing to what would happen next, that explanation is coded under consequences. Ranking the six dimensions by frequency shows how often each reason appears across students’ explanations. Because the abstract reports no percentages, you cannot tell how wide the gap between consequences and intentions and motivations is, or whether that gap would hold in a different group of students.
Does the Type of Dilemma Change Reasoning?
Yes. In this study, the kind of dilemma changed which moral dimension students emphasized, so the overall ranking does not describe every scenario equally well. Legal questions drew more attention to principles and rights, so students in those scenarios talked more often about rules, entitlements, and what people are owed. Dilemmas involving friends prompted more concern for care and relationships, with students weighing how a choice would affect the bond between people.
| Dilemma context | Dominant dimension highlighted by the study | What the pattern suggests |
|---|---|---|
| Legal questions | Principles and rights | Rules, entitlements, and obligations come to the foreground when the law is part of the choice. |
| Dilemmas involving friends | Care and relationships | Personal bonds and their maintenance shape reasoning more than abstract rules do. |
| All ten dilemmas combined | Consequences, followed by intentions and motivations | Outcomes are the most common reason students give across everyday choices in general. |
The study reports these context-specific patterns qualitatively rather than as percentages, so you can see the direction of each shift. Read the table as a map of tendencies in this sample, not as a measurement of each scenario.
Same Dimension, Opposite Decisions

Students sometimes reached opposite decisions while drawing on the same moral dimension. The authors say their findings describe the considerations students chose to articulate, not every influence on their judgments. A coded reason is therefore a stated reason, not a complete record of why each student acted.
Illustration, not a finding from the study: Imagine two students who both cite fairness after a group project goes wrong. One argues that fairness requires reporting a teammate who did no work, since everyone else carried an equal load. The other argues that fairness requires covering for a teammate whose family emergency kept her from contributing. Both value fairness, yet they disagree about the facts and about which fairness claim matters more.
The Limits of College Moral Reasoning Data
Earlier research gives this study a useful backdrop. Lawrence Kohlberg’s theory of moral judgment described development through conventional and principled stages, and many earlier college studies measured students against that framework. The Defining Issues Test is a widely used instrument for measuring moral reasoning, which is why it appears so often in comparisons. Earlier high-profile studies also examined education level, cross-cultural samples such as a Kuwait University student study, and U.S. college-educated adults discussing sociopolitical issues.
The October 2026 study rests on one U.S. sample of 136 undergraduates and their written explanations. That makes it a starting point for understanding this group and these ten scenarios, not a universal profile of college students. The study’s six-dimension coding also differs from stage-based and test-based measures, so its counts should not be read as stage scores or compared directly with Kohlberg or Defining Issues Test results.
Using This Data in Your Own Research or Teaching
If you are teaching, try a short exercise. Give students one everyday dilemma involving a friend and one involving a legal question, ask them to choose a course of action, and have them write a brief reason for each choice. Then have them sort each reason into the six dimensions. Students can check whether the friend scenario pulls them toward care and relationships and the legal scenario toward principles and rights, as the study’s patterns would suggest.
If you are researching, read the full article in Precollege Philosophy and Public Practice before you quote any count. Look closely at how coders assigned explanations to dimensions and whether one explanation could fall under more than one. Because the abstract reports no percentages, treat any exact share you need as a question for the full text, not something to assume.
Frequently Asked Questions
1. Where can I read the full DePauw study and its repository record?
The full article, Jillian Lee Meyer and Ted Bitner’s “Morality and Me: An Investigation of a Moral Framework for College Students,” appears in Precollege Philosophy and Public Practice under DOI 10.5840/p4202693032. You can find the study’s repository record, which includes the abstract and publication details. Read the full text before quoting any count, because the abstract reports no percentages.
2. How does the six-dimension coding framework differ from Kohlberg’s stages?
Kohlberg’s theory places people in ordered developmental stages, moving from conventional rule-following toward principled judgment. The six-dimension scheme instead sorts the reasons students give into categories such as consequences, care and relationships, and fairness, without placing any student on a developmental ladder. For that reason, the study’s counts describe which reasons students mention and should not be read as Kohlberg stage scores.
3. Can this data be used to compare moral reasoning on my own campus?
You can borrow the study’s ten-dilemma format and six-dimension coding as a model for a local project, but the published results come from 136 U.S. undergraduates and cannot stand in for your campus. A campus comparison would need its own sample of students, similar dilemmas, and consistent coding of their written explanations. Matching your findings against the DePauw results would also require the full text, since the abstract gives no percentages to compare against.
4. Does a college education make students more morally developed?
Answering that question would require a study that compares college students with people who never attended college and follows the same students over several years, using a measure aimed at development rather than the reasons students name in a set of dilemmas.



